Skip to content
2 min read TRUE NATURE

Are we nature?

I thought I knew the answer, but I'd failed to spot some of the implications 🌿

Are we nature?
Craig y Cilau escarpment, Llangattock: all of it shaped by human activity | Photo by Giles

So I’m idly browsing twitter, as you do, and the algorithm’s served me up some guy, talking about whether or not humans are part of nature.

“Ooh, I know a thing or two about that,” says the Giles Ego Construct (the GEC: 📦) and off it goes, reading and nodding.

At one point in the thread, he says:

“We are not separate from the rest of nature…”

📦: [Concurs, nods silently]

Then he goes on…

“And logically, that extends to everything we make. A termite mound and a White Stork’s nest are natural, but so is a car park, a woodland razed to the ground and a stone wall.”

Say what, now?

📦: 😶

📦: 🤔

📦: 😮

📦: 🤯

Because, dear reader, for the Giles Ego Construct 📦 head-canon, that was very much not the case.

As I said in my reply to him,

“This tweet has given me pause for thought, thank you. While seeing humans as inseparable from nature, I have always mentally categorised the outputs of humans (e.g. roads/buildings) as lifeless and ‘non-natural’ but I realise the hypocrisy of this view now!”

(You see, polite discourse on social media is possible 😉)

So now, every time I’m out on my bike, admiring all the non-human-created things that I specifically go out of my way to surround myself with, I’m reminded of this, and I relax into my wrongness.

Between you and me I’ve not even formed a new belief about this one yet. It was only five days ago and I have no idea what to think about it all.

But that in itself is quite nice.

Not knowing. Close cousin of Being Wrong. I like them both.

Anyway, let me know what your Reader Ego Construct 📦 has to say about this, in the comments, below!

💟

Giles 

p.s. I can't talk about this without pointing you to this timeless, insightful track from Howard Jones, called Natural:

“Everything around us is natural
Don't fight it
Don't disagree with this and that.
Everything we like and don't like is whole and natural
I know is doesn't feel like it and the world seems wrong
But if we don't like it now then who can we blame
Blame God, be still, find harmony.”
In celebration of being wrong
Do you want to be right or do you want to be happy? ◑

I love being wrong. Being wrong is when misunderstanding falls away.